Shobhit Sharma
Posted on:May 1, 2025 at 06:30 PM5 min read

When good enough is not good enough

I like to read code, I love to write code. I also like to write about code.

I’ve been programming for a long time and I’ve seen a lot of code. I’ve seen good code and I’ve seen bad code.

I’ve also seen code that is just not good enough.

With the rise of AI, we are now able to generate code at an unprecedented scale. However, this has also brought a new problem: when good enough is not good enough.

[!NOTE] Key Takeaways

  • The Prototype Trap: Vibe coding excels at rapid prototyping, but “good enough” code rapidly decays when exposed to production traffic, concurrency, and edge cases.
  • The Cost of Black Boxes: Accepting AI-generated solutions without deeply understanding failure modes creates fragile systems that are impossible to troubleshoot during outages.
  • Craft Over Convenience: High-velocity AI code generation must be balanced with deterministic testing, strong architectural boundaries, and strict code review standards.

Vibe coding

This is not a blog about bashing vibe coding. I am a big fan of vibe coding.

Being able to prompt an idea into existence in an afternoon is nothing short of magical. It lowers the barrier to entry, speeds up prototyping, and makes experimenting with new concepts genuinely delightful. For throwaway prototypes, hackathons, or internal tools with zero longevity requirements, “vibe coding” is incredible.

The trouble begins when vibe coding meets production systems.

The Illusion of Working Code

AI coding assistants are exceptionally good at producing code that looks right and compiles. On happy paths, the generated code often behaves as expected. The UI renders, the endpoint responds with 200 OK, and the database record is inserted.

It’s tempting to think: “Hey, it works. Good enough.”

Except “good enough” in software is rarely static. It decays rapidly under the weight of real-world constraints:

  • Missing Edge Cases: What happens when the network drops mid-stream? What happens when the input contains unexpected unicode characters or null values?
  • Silent Concurrency Failures: Race conditions, deadlocks, and connection pool exhaustion don’t show up in a 10-second local test.
  • Architectural Drift: LLMs generate code in isolation. They solve the immediate prompt without recognizing that a shared utility or domain abstraction already exists three folders away.
  • Security Vulnerabilities: Subtly insecure defaults—missing input validation, unchecked deserialization, or unindexed database queries—quietly pile up.

When an engineer understands the entire system, they write code with an eye toward future failure modes. When an engineer relies solely on the vibe, they inherit a black box that they can’t debug when things inevitably fail at 2 AM.

Good Enough vs. Production Grade

There is an enormous difference between code that passes a demo and code that survives production.

Metric“Good Enough” (Vibe Coded)Production Grade
TestingUntested or surface-level happy pathUnit, integration, and regression tests covering failure modes
Error HandlingGeneric catch (e) or unhandled rejectionsTyped error domains, structured logging, graceful degradation
Observabilityconsole.logStructured metrics, tracing, actionable alerting
Data IntegrityAssumed idempotency, missing transactionsAtomic commits, constraint enforcement, migration paths
MaintainabilityEphemeral, opaque prompt artifactsClean abstractions, documented intent, easy to refactor

When you accept “good enough” too early in the product lifecycle, you aren’t saving time—you’re borrowing against future development velocity at exorbitant interest rates.

The Balance: AI as Accelerator, Human as Architect

The solution isn’t to reject AI tools. That would be like rejecting compilers or high-level languages. The solution is to redefine our relationship with them.

  1. Own the Architecture First: Never let an AI make structural or domain boundary decisions for your application. Define the interfaces, schemas, and system invariants yourself.
  2. Review with Skepticism: Treat every AI-generated diff with the same rigor you’d apply to an unverified third-party library or an intern’s first PR.
  3. Double Down on Tests: If you use AI to write code fast, use that saved time to write comprehensive automated tests. A suite of deterministic tests is your only safeguard against AI hallucinations and regressions.
  4. Know When to Say “Not Good Enough”: If you don’t understand how a piece of generated code works down to the database or runtime level, don’t ship it. Take the extra thirty minutes to comprehend it, simplify it, or rewrite it.

Conclusion

Vibe coding is great for starting. Craftsmanship is what keeps things running.

AI gives us superpower speed, but speed without direction is just a faster way to make a mess. In an era where anyone can generate a thousand lines of code in seconds, the ability to discern what is truly production-ready—and to reject what is merely “good enough”—is the ultimate engineering skill.

Share:

Open to Collaboration

Hey there! If you've got a new project brewing in your head, or just want to share something cool, or even just drop a casual hi, please feel free to hit me up! It's always great to connect with folks who stop by, so don't be shy!